Sunday, 17 July 2011

The Good News: We Have Today


What if you were told that of the eight people closest to you, you only had enough food to feed one. One would survive, the other seven would not. How do you go about deciding who to feed? Imagine how difficult it would to be decide which of your children you would save. It is an impossible dilemma, and one that Dr. James Lovelock believes will become inevitable by 2100.

Lovelock’s Predictions
  • By 2020 extreme weather will be the norm, resulting in global devastation.
  • By 2040 Europe will have a Saharan climate, while much of the UK will be underwater.
  • By 2100 Europe and Australia’s climates will be 8° Celsius hotter than the present.
  • By 2100 food shortages and mass starvation will wipe out seven eighths of the world’s population, with an estimated 1 billion people surviving.
The Gaia Hypothesis
James Lovelock is an independent environmental scientist, best known as the originator of the Gaia hypothesis. His Gaia hypothesis proposes that all organisms and their surroundings on Earth are closely integrated to form the living, self-regulating system known as Gaia. Gaia’s goal is to provide an optimal environment for life, and she (Gaia) regulates herself to achieve this goal. Through the observation of paleoclimate data, Lovelock has concluded that increased greenhouse gas levels have forced Gaia into an unstable state. He determines that humanity has pushed Gaia to regulate herself into a state of much hotter temperatures, making much of earth uninhabitable for humans. Lovelock foresees Gaia arriving at this hotter steady state by 2100, and warns that drastic climate changes will result in massive food shortages, resulting in the deaths of seven eighths of the world’s population. 

Why I Believe Lovelock
Before you dismiss Lovelock’s observations as merely a potential cover for the National Enquirer, consider the following:

He’s One of the Preeminent Scientists of Our Time
  • Fellow of the Royal Society.
  • Formally a leading researcher at NASA, Oxford, Harvard and Yale.
  • Became an independent researcher in 1964, to allow himself more freedom and creativity in his research.
His Past Predictions have Proven Correct
  • He was the first to detect the widespread existence of CFCs in the atmosphere.
  • While working for NASA in the 1960s, he correctly predicted that NASA’s attempts to find life on Mars would be unsuccessful, as his observations had proven Mars’ atmosphere to be uninhabitable.
  • In 1965, Shell Oil asked him what the world would look like in 2000, and he predicted that we would be facing grave environmental problems.
  • His theory of Earth being a living self-regulating system was initially ridiculed. It is now the consensus.
  • The UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) is slowly accepting his climate change observations.
Thoughts
What I take away from Lovelock’s observations is that our future is uncertain. Then again haven’t we always known this? Hasn’t tomorrow always been a mystery?

Lovelock merely refocuses our attention on life’s uncertainty— it’s brevity. So what do we do in the face of life’s uncertainty?

Embrace it! Enjoy the moment, enjoy today, because as Lovelock demonstrates, and we have always known, the future is uncertain.


Further Watching:
1. James Lovelock interview with George Stroumboulopoulos (If you had told me 10 years ago that he'd go from MuchMusic punk rocker to Canada's Letterman, I would have called you nuts!)


2. James Lovelock presentation of his latest book, The Vanishing Face of Gaia

Thursday, 14 July 2011

The Inescapable Debt



This US debt defaulting drama is everywhere, there's no escaping it— it wakes me up on the radio, covers my newspaper, and is the discussion amongst my classmates as I enter class. It is time for me to put forth my thoughts especially in regards to how it affects sustainable economics. 

Politics or Economics?

What strikes me most is how the disagreement is much more political than economical. I say this because the correct economic choice is obvious; the debt limit must be increased (or removed altogether) and the debt cut gradually. It is the ABCs of economics: in a recession/ recovering from a recession you maintain or increase government expenditure so to facilitate growth; in an expansion/ when the economy is doing well you can lower government expenditure so to keep inflation stable. The Republicans demand of cutting trillions from federal spending is bad policy as it would set the economy back amid decreased demand and increased unemployment. 

It must be frustrating for Americans to watch this ongoing political posturing as both sides are more concerned with looking tough for the upcoming election than they are about doing what’s best for the country. Neither side wants to concede to the other’s demands. Worst of all neither side will even entertain the idea of getting rid of the arbitrary debt limit (the US is the only advanced economy with one) as doing so is said to be ‘political suicide’.

This problem of political self-interest has long undermined effective economic policy. The issue is that the nation’s goals and those of the politicians who make decisions on behalf of the nation are not aligned. The central aim of a politician is to be re-elected, not to do what’s best for the nation.

Until this problem is fixed, the best option (in this case dismissing the debt limit) will all too often be overlooked in favor of what looks best politically.

Questions
- How sustainable is it to finance the present economy through borrowing?

- At what point does continued borrowing become unsustainable and overly burdensome?



The good news is that for better or for worse, the ordeal will finally be over August 2nd.
I can hardly wait.

Worth Reading:

CBS News debt limit primer

Monday, 11 July 2011

The Tragedy of the Commons



Hello readers,

            Today I’d like to present my thoughts on the present-day relevance of Garrett Hardin’s classic discourse entitled “The Tragedy of the Commons”. Written in 1968, the article was the first attempt at a solution for common resources. Economists define common resources as non-excludable (there are no property rights, therefore anyone can use them) and rivalrous (one person’s consumption limits the consumption of another person).
            Hardin’s example involves a pasture open to all and a number of herdsmen who will keep as many cattle on the pasture as possible. The size of the land is fixed, and eventually the pasture will become over populated, as each herdsman will benefit from continuing to add cattle. The rationale of the herdsman for adding an additional animal is as follows:

Positive: The herdsman receives all the proceeds from the sale of the additional animal

Negative: The additional overgrazing created by the one more animal. The effects of this overgrazing are shared equally by all the herdsman, thus making the private cost to the individual herdsman a fraction of the total social cost to the pasture as a whole.

            Given the incentive, each individual herdsman will continue to add cattle even though it is harmful to the pasture as a whole.

            I have brought forth the example of the Tragedy of the Commons, because it applies directly to the problem of pollution. Pollution is the reverse of Hardin’s pasture, rather than taking something out of the commons, we are putting in. The problem is that what we are putting in­­—greenhouse gas emission into the air, sewage and chemicals into the water— is harmful. And the pollution continues as the rationale man finds his share of the cost of the waste he pollutes into the commons to be less than the cost he would face to purify his wastes before releasing them.
             It becomes obvious that pollution will continue until it becomes cheaper for each polluter to treat his pollutants than to discharge them untreated.

The question becomes—How do we make it cheaper to treat pollutants/not pollute than to pollute?

-       A tax is definitely needed. Given that rich people and nations pollute the most, I propose a stepped-tax system either with higher taxes in wealthier nations/regions, or with the tax increasing at higher levels of pollution/emissions. It might be as simple as taxing less fuel-efficient vehicles substantially more. The key here is that the tax must make it cheaper not to pollute. In practice, this has been difficult to establish; for example, carbon taxes have had little effect on reducing emissions as they are to low.

Let me know if you have any other ideas,

AC

Thursday, 7 July 2011

The Discounting Debate


            The central reason that the Stern Review’s recommendations have not come to fruition is that The Review’s critics contend that Stern improperly handles future generations. The question of how to treat future outcomes relative to present ones has long been debated by philosophers and economists alike. We shall return to the debate, but first let’s look at the consumption discount rate, δ, which is currently the tool used by economists to handle the question of futurity. The discount rate is the rate at which society is willing to trade present benefits for future ones. It may be useful to think of the discount rate as similar to the interest rate given by banks. Like with banks, future consumption is less valuable than present consumption. A dollar today is more valuable than a dollar in the future. The discount rate formula is:

δ = ρ + gη

where ρ is the social rate of time preference, g is the projected growth rate of average consumption, and η is the elasticity of the social weight attributed to a change in consumption.
So what does it all mean?
            Let’s start with g, which is simply the projected growth of the economy. For example, if we project the economy to grow at 1% annually, then we put 0.01 in for g.
            Next we’ll turn to η, which accounts for the fact that as consumption grows, the marginal value of consumption decreases. It is derived from the economic law of diminishing returns. For instance, a poor person with a low level of consumption will value a $1 increase in income much more than will a rich person with a high level of consumption. Another example, if hungry, we enjoy our first piece of pizza much more than say the tenth piece. The parameter η is relatively uncontroversial; there is a consensus with it being between one and three.
            We are now ready to return to the exciting debate of whether the future should be discounted simply because it is the future. This matter is contained in ρ, the social rate of time preference. On the one side we have the position of most philosophers who argue that present generations have the moral obligation to protect the interests of future generations. They maintain that a value of zero for ρ would ensure equality across generations as it prevents the present generation from ignoring the long-term environmental consequences of present-day activities.  For instance, positive values of ρ can lead to almost entirely devaluing disastrous environment impacts that occur over 50 years into the future. Nicholas Stern endorses this view as his Stern Review uses a value of 0 for ρ.
            Most economists support the other side of the debate. Their view is that investments made in the economy today will increase the wealth of future generations thus making them more able to respond to any environmental issues. The view relies on the optimism that technology, wealth, and human ingenuity will be able to solve any future environmental problem. For example, there is a large group of climate change skeptics who believe that the problem can be solved in the future by merely sucking the greenhouse gases from the atmosphere-like a vacuum (crazy right).
            Stern uses a low discount rate, one that many economists disagree with. Moreover, they oppose his conclusions and recommendations because of the discount rate disagreement. It is no wonder then that policy makers cannot come to a consensus on a plan when economists cannot settle their own discounting debate.

All for now,
AC

Tuesday, 5 July 2011

The Stern Review

Good Afternoon Everyone,

            In writing a sustainable economics blog, it would be rather irresponsible of me if I overlooked the contribution of Sir Nicholas Stern. In 2006, Nic Stern published the infamous (at least among economists) Stern Review on the Economics of Climate Change. Much of the credit for the recent increase in climate change discourse should be directed at Stern, though Al Gore deserves credit too (Gore more for getting the word out there, Stern actually provides the content and research- 600 pages of it!). I’m going to share with you some of the key aspects of climate change, as described by Stern, that people are generally unaware of.


 1. Rich countries contributed much more to climate change than do poor ones. (Image from Jonathan A. Patz et al, 2007)
2. Poor countries will face the greatest negative impacts from climate change. (Image from Jonathan A. Patz et al, 2007)
      
      3. There is considerable uncertainty regarding how much temperatures will increase, and how the economy will be affected. Stern predicts with 90% confidence that temperatures will rise anywhere from 2.6 Degrees Celsius to 6.5 Degrees Celsius. The economic implications of this increase in temperature are even less certain; some economists even contend that climate change is a good thing and will yield greater output (their rationale centers on northern Russia and Canada becoming more habitable and better suited for agriculture). Stern's estimates add to the uncertainty as he predicts the range of losses in 2200 to be between 2.7 and 32.6 percent of GDP per capita.

        4. About half of the measures Stern recommends taking to lessen the affects of global warming will come at a negative cost-they will both decrease emissions and save money. Examples include switching to more efficient: insulation, lighting, and transportation.

                Stern concludes that we must act immediately to avoid the catastrophic effects of global warming; however, drastic action has not yet been taken. Why?
      
     Answer coming next (hint it involves the discount rate)


Population 7 billion



Hello Everyone,

            Last week, while waiting for an appointment, I came across the January 2011 issue of National Geographic. It was the cover’s title of “Population 7 billion” that caught my eye. The normally unbearably long wait went by very quickly as I found myself lost in the article. The report noted that population levels are currently at around 7 billion and will continue to climb to 9 billion by 2045. It predicted that upon reaching 9 billion, population growth would cease and remain fairly constant around the 9 billion mark.

            How did National Geographic arrive at the trend of population growth to 9 billion and then remaining constant?

            They observe that while fertility rates (e.g. the average number of children born to a woman over her lifetime) have declined to approximately the replacement level (fertility rate needed to maintain the population) of 2.1, many nations have a disproportionately large amount of children and adolescents. The glut of children is an effect of previous fertility rates that were overly high. The consequence becomes that when these children become adults, they will contribute to increasing population growth even if the fertility rate is at replacement level. National Geographic predicts that this trend will conclude at around 2045 as by then there will have been consecutive generations with stable fertility rates and thus population stability will be achieved.

            It was an interesting read, here’s the link: http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/2011/01/seven-billion/kunzig-text/1

It got me thinking; can earth support the 9 billion inhabitants predicted for 2045?

Monday, 4 July 2011

The First Attempt at Sustainable Economic Development

            Today’s discussion relates to this short article (only 4 pages!). So please take a look: http://www.vwl.unibe.ch/studies/3016_e/Hartwick.pdf . Note- don’t get too caught up on the complicated math formulas, focus on the written content and ideas.
            One of the first attempts at providing a formula for sustainable economic development came from John M. Hartwick way back in 1977. Hartwick hypothesized that to avoid hurting future generations by over-consuming today, we must “invest all profits or rents from exhaustible resources in reproducible capital such as machines.” To clarify, ‘rents’ is essentially the same as profits, it is the difference between the selling price of the resource and the resources’ production cost. Stated simply, Hartwick is endorsing taking all profits from non-renewable resources (oil, natural gas, coal, gold etc.) and investing them in physical capital (machines, buildings, infrastructure etc.).

Does Hartwick’s idea lead to sustainability?
           
            My opinion is that Hartwick’s formula would not successfully lead to sustainable economic growth. Unsuccessful because it does not include the negative environmental externalities that come with both the extraction and use of natural resources, and the building of physical capital. Negative externalities are the social costs that not accounted for in the market. For example, automobile pollution is a negative externality of transportation. One method of accounting for the externality would be putting a tax on gasoline. Nevertheless, here are some examples of negative externalities that would adversely affect the sustainability of Hartwick’s plan:

·      --The considerable environmental damages from resource extraction:
            -Ecosystem and wildlife disturbances from extraction sites
            -Noise pollution, air pollution, and greenhouse gas emissions from extraction

·      --The air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions from oil, coal, and natural gas combustion
·      --The substantial air and noise pollution that comes with building of physical capital

            Consequently, when factoring in these environmental externalities I arrive at the conclusion that Hartwick’s theory is not a sufficient condition for sustainable economic development.

Here are a couple other questions that I thought of when reading Hartwick’s article:

            1. How do you account for the depreciation of physical capital? It seems to me that physical                   capital depreciates much faster than natural capital (further research needed here).
            2. How do we account for the possibility that extraction costs increase- thereby making profits decrease- as resource reserves deplete?
           


All for now!

AC